Vital Football

Latest Dundee United News

Fans & Refs Agree - It Shouldve Been A Penalty

Fans & Refs Agree - It Shouldve Been A Penalty

Its not often that football supporters agree with a referee, but last week Dundee United supporters found themselves agreeing with referee Kenny Clark`s view of the penalty claim against Celtic.

In a poll on, an amazing 85% of voters thought that it was a stonewall penalty for Dundee United, after Roy O`Donovan had been brought down by Gary Caldwell at the edge of the 6-yard box.

It should have been a spot-kick to United, but referee Charlie Richmond shockingly waved away the claims, allowing Celtic defender Gary Caldwell to also escaped a possible red card, because he`d already been booked earlier in the game.

However, Clark thinks the bizarre decision was more down to the way that O`Donovan fell, rather than an Old Firm conspiracy among Scottish referees.

"Charlie turned down what was a clear penalty after Gary Caldwell tripped Roy O`Donovan in the box," admitted Kenny Clark to the Daily Record.

"I can only assume Charlie was put off by the theatrical way O'Donovan went down. The Irishman over-egged the pudding."

"If he`d fallen normally there`s every chance he`d have got the penalty but sometimes in thinking they`ll convince the official players end up overdoing it."

"I suspect that's what's happened here but at the end of the day it's an error of judgement from Charlie. Simple as that."

There was no indecision in the poll over the incident, as only a handful of suspect Celtic supporters tried to skew the results.

85% of voters were clearly aggrieved at Richmond`s biased decision, with only 15% saying it shouldn`t have been a penalty...probably Celtic fans!

Final results:
Should United Have Been Awarded A Penalty Against Celtic?
5% = Yes
5% = No
% = Dont Know

Related Links
Vital Football:
Dundee United Site
Latest SPL News
Club Menu:
Arab News
Match Previews/Reports
Fixtures/League Tables
Match Stats
Ref Watch
Arab Articles
Arab Polls
Arab Competitions
Half-Time Quizzes
Arab Facts
Arab Humour
Arab Songbook
Dufc History
Trophy Cabinet
Managerial History
Away From Home
SPL Firsts (2007/08)
Squad Profiles
ArabFC Polls
Other Links
Arab Articles:
Welcome to ArabFC
A Lovely Shade Of Tangerine
The History Of The Tangerine
Why Are Utd Fans Called Arabs?
Contribute To ArabFC:
The Big Appeal
Suggest An Article
Suggest A Poll
Have Your Say:
Sign Up To ArabFC
Dundee United Forums
All SPL Forums

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Tactful Sheik
Date:Wednesday August 27 2008
Time: 8:00AM

Best of Vital Scottish Football

Dundee United - Dundee United 2 Dumbarton 1

Celtic - Rangers v Celtic


The penalty claim was no different than tha one Naka got booked for last season.Referees are pretty much incompitent in Scotland.They want a decent wage they tell us, well all we want is decent referees
27/08/2008 09:07:00
Looked a stonewall penalty
Red Wimp
16/09/2008 22:08:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Dundee United Articles

Dundee United 2 Dumbarton 1

Dundee United are now in second place in the Championship following their 2-1 victory against Dumbarton at Tannadice.

The Tangerines were boosted by a Mark Docherty own-goal early in the second-half and William Edjenguele soon added another from close-in.

However, Robert Thomson replied for the visitors from substitute Andy Stirling's delivery with seventeen minutes remaining.

The hosts should really have been in front on six minutes when Willo Flood released Nick van der Ve

Boss hails victory

Dundee United manager Ray McKinnon hailed a "fine" three points following the 2-1 victory against Dumbarton at Tannadice.

Stats: Dundee United v Dumbarton

All the stats from Dundee United (2) vs (1) Dumbarton, Tannadice, Sat 22nd Oct 3.00pm Att: 5,979

Team Line-Ups: Dundee United v Dumbarton

Team line-ups for Dundee United v Dumbarton at Tannadice.

Archived Vital Arabs Articles

Vital Arabs articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Ray McKinnon was the right choice as manager?
Suggested By: Vital Arabs

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Celtic 8 7 1 0 22 18
2 Aberdeen 9 5 3 1 18 9
3 Hearts 9 5 2 2 17 9
4 Rangers 9 4 3 2 15 0
5 St. Johnstone 9 4 2 3 14 2
6 Inverness 10 2 4 4 10 -5
7 Ross County 10 2 4 4 10 -6
8 Kilmarnock 10 2 4 4 10 -10
9 Motherwell 9 2 3 4 9 -3
10 Hamilton 9 1 5 3 8 -4
11 Partick 9 1 4 4 7 -4
12 Dundee 9 1 3 5 6 -6
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Dundee United Results (view all)

Dundee United Fixtures (view all)

Nov 8 2016 7:45PM : Dunfermline Athletic (H)
Scottish Championship
Nov 12 2016 12:30PM : Dunfermline Athletic (a)
Petrofac Training Cup
Dec 2 2016 7:45PM : Hibernian (H)
Scottish Championship
Dec 31 2016 3:00PM : Dumbarton (a)
Scottish Championship
Jan 6 2017 7:45PM : Hibernian (a)
Scottish Championship
Jan 14 2017 3:00PM : Queen of the South (H)
Scottish Championship
The Vital Football Members League