Writer: Arab Jacques
Date:Wednesday November 29 2006
Dundee United supporters are desperate to see the talented Charlie Miller back at Tannadice, but will Chairman Eddie Thompson agree?
The 30-year-old midfielder is reported to be looking for a move back to Scotland after spending the last 2 years playing for SK Brann Bergen in Norway.
Miller signed for Dundee United on a free transfer in November 2000, but was released by the club in July 2004 after Eddie Thompson decided he couldn`t justify paying the players inflated wages.
A favorite with Dundee United supporters, Miller was influential in the centre of the United midfield and occasionally grabbed a few goals of his own (17 in 109 appearances), but he was too inconsistent and his physical fitness was always in doubt.
Craig Levein is looking to add a few players to his current squad when the transfer window re-opens in January and the talents of Charlie Miller would be a great addition to any team, but could Dundee United afford to pay the wages Miller would want?
The majority of Dundee United supporters think that Eddie Thompson should bring Glasgow born Charlie Miller back to Tannadice - no matter what the cost.
In a poll on Vital Football (Dundee United), over 70% of supporters voted in favour of the midfielder returning to Tannadice, with only 12% voting against it.
Although some supporters didn`t think the club should break the bank to get Miller, with 10% saying he should only return if the price was right, whilst another 3% were concerned that Miller`s mental attitude could make it too risky a signing.
However, there was a further 13% of those polled, who didn`t think it was even up to United supporters and have decided to give manager Craig Levein the benefit of the doubt.
Ultimately, it will be Levein`s decision whether the club would benefit from Miller returning, but Levein is a very demanding manager and might not want such an inconsistent player, despite the overall benefits it would bring to the squad.
The younger players could learn from him, but that could include the bad habits, as well as the good ones, but at least the United supporters would be happy at Miller being back in the squad…
Full Results: Should Charlie Miller Return To Tannadice?
61% = Yes, definitely - whatever the cost
10% = Yes, but only if the price is right
3% = Maybe, if he's changed his attitude
2% = No, Levein wouldn't want him
11% = No, he's not worth it - too inconsistent
13% = Don't Know - ultimately its Levein's decision.
Date:Wednesday November 29 2006
McNamara faces immediate return (Wednesday June 19 2013)
Tangerines chase additions (Saturday June 15 2013)
United make settlement (Friday June 14 2013)
No second thoughts from Russell (Tuesday June 11 2013)
Former striker so proud (Tuesday June 11 2013)
Russell happy to cross border (Monday June 10 2013)
Rams complete striker raid (Monday June 10 2013)
Move set for completion (Monday June 10 2013)
Rovers reject striker approach (Saturday June 8 2013)
Tangerines face wait on strikers (Saturday June 8 2013)
|3. Dundee United||0||0||0||0||+0||0|
|Defender in talks with Celtic
» Celtic : 20/06/2013 11:04:00
|McNamara faces immediate return
» Dundee United : 19/06/2013 10:36:00
|Title defence begins at Parkhead
» Celtic : 19/06/2013 10:17:00
|Defender fixes sights on Celtic
» Celtic : 18/06/2013 11:25:00
|Celtic linked with second defender
» Celtic : 17/06/2013 22:13:00
|Celtic in defender link
» Celtic : 17/06/2013 11:30:00
|Royals step up chase
» Celtic : 15/06/2013 17:17:00