Vital Football

Latest Dundee United News

SPL Managers Not Allowed An Opinion

SPL Managers Not Allowed An Opinion

Scottish football managers clearly aren't allowed to have an opinion about referees, otherwise they are made to suffer by the SFA.

This season several SPL managers have been fined for voicing their concerns about certain decisions - with Saint Mirren boss Gus MacPherson fined £500 the other day for his comments during the Dundee United Scottish Cup match on the 16th of January.

Although, MacPherson's comments weren't specifically aimed at one single decision made by the match referee, but at the attitude of one of the linesmen.

During his after-match interview, the Buddies manager went berserk and starting criticising assistant referee James Bee for what he called an "arrogant" response.

"I made a comment to the referee and he [James Bee] came back with an arrogant remark. His arrogance beggars belief," said MacPherson after the match.

Dundee United beat Saint Mirren with a late strike from David Robertson giving Craig Levein's side a 3-2 victory.

"I've been asked to clarify the remarks, and I've sent a response saying I stand by them," admitted MacPherson last month when asked to clarify his comments by the SFA.

"I said at the time, I felt the remarks were justified. It's a decision for the SFA's general purposes committee, whether they decide to take it a stage further, but they were also asking if the quotes attributed to myself were accurate."

"The quotes that were highlighted in the luminous pen that was highlighting them were accurate, but as I say, I stand by them."

It's no surprise that MacPherson is expected to appeal the decision, perhaps he should claim that not allowing him to have an opinion is an infringement of his human rights?

Ironically, Dundee United's Craig Levein is one of the few managers to apologise to a referee this season, after an incident in a goalless SPL clash with Dunfermline at the end of January.

Levein was sure that Jon Daly had been brought down in the penalty box, but referee Dougie McDonald had a better view of the incident and saw that it was infact Craig Conway that had knocked over his teammate Daly.

At the post-match interview Levein criticised the referee, but after watching a replay of the incident offered the Scottish whistler a full apology for getting the decision spot-on.

Related Links
Vital Football:
Dundee United Site
Latest SPL News
More United News:
News Archive
Irish Influx Expected In The Summer?
Magic Boots - At A Cinema Near You?
Dundee Upset By Result Of Coin Toss
Levein Goes Scouting For Talent
More Injury Worries For Craig Levein
Celtic Can Still Beat AC Milan
Weekend Used For Shooting Practice
Goodwillie Not Joining Airdrie...Yet
We Benefit From Watching AC Milan
Only £251,535 Behind Hull City?
Have Your Say:
Dundee United Forums
All SPL Forums


Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Writer:Arab Jacques
Date:Thursday March 1 2007
Time: 12:33PM

Comments

0
There's nothing new in this though is there? You can't say anything about these guys. However I would be interested to know exactly what Gus says the linesman said to him......maybe the reason he's unkeen to say is that he'd be quite embarrassed about the fracas he's caused about nothing.
MrH
01/03/2007 13:00:00
0
Wouldnt be surprised if it was a 4-letter word, but since MacPherson probably shouts many of them over the course of a match - its bound to be a case of pots & kettles!
ArabJacques
01/03/2007 13:15:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Dundee United Articles

United selection crisis easing

Dundee United manager Csaba Laszlo is relieved to finally see his injury problems beginning to ease.

Midfielder sent out on loan

Dundee United's teenage midfielder Scott Allardice has been allowed to join East Fife on loan.

Boss unhappy with defending

Dundee United manager Csaba Laszlo was critical of the defending during the 4-2 defeat at Aberdeen in the Scottish Cup.

Aberdeen 4 Dundee United 2

Gary Mackay-Steven scored twice against his former club as Dundee United went down 4-2 at Aberdeen in the Scottish Cup fifth round.

Adam Rooney earned the hosts a twentieth-minute lead and Mackay-Steven added to it before Sam Stanton replied at the other end.

But Kenny McLean immediately headed in for a 3-1 interval advantage that was improved upon by Mackay-Steven early in the second-half.

Substitute Paul McMullan then grabbed a second for the visitors with twenty minutes r

Dundee United Archived Articles

Vital Arabs articles from

Site Journalists

Malpas
Editor email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Ray McKinnon was the right choice as manager?
Suggested By: Vital Arabs
Yes78%
No22%
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Dundee United Results (view all)

Vital Football Comment